Some people find peace and comfort in a church or in being a part of its community. But sometimes, a church that seems welcoming and friendly on the surface might have underlying issues. Knowing what to watch for can help ensure your church experience is healthy and supportive.
Here are 17 red flags that might indicate problems within a church. Keeping an eye out for these signs can protect your spiritual well-being and ensure you’re in the right community that will truly support and uplift you.
Constant Focus on Money
When a place of worship focuses more on contributions, donations, or financial targets rather than nurturing your spiritual journey, it can give the impression that they are more interested in what’s in your wallet than your spiritual well-being. If you ever feel compelled to contribute or “donate” funds regularly and not voluntarily, it might be time to reflect on whether this resonates with your beliefs.
Lack of Openness
Transparency is always the key. When a church keeps its financial matters, decision-making, or even fundamental details to itself, it can breed suspicion. Being kept unaware of operations or the allocation of funds can be a major red flag.
Controlling Behavior
Religious figures should offer direction rather than exert authority. When you sense that the church is attempting to dictate your decisions or meddle in your personal matters when you don’t even want them to, it blurs the boundary between support and overstepping, which is not healthy for anyone.
“We’re the Only Right Church” Mentality
A church that insists it’s the only true path to salvation and looks down on other beliefs can be divisive. This attitude can create an environment of exclusivity and can make you feel like there’s no room for diverse perspectives and exploration.
Unquestionable Leadership
Healthy spiritual leadership welcomes questions and discussions. If leaders demand unquestioning obedience and discourage you from asking questions, it could be a sign of authoritarian behavior that stifles growth and trust.
Gossip Culture
A church where gossip and negative talk are common, especially from the pulpit, can be toxic. It’s important for a church to promote kindness and respect rather than spreading rumors and negativity.
Playing Favorites
When some members receive special treatment or perks while others are ignored and overlooked, it can create an unfair environment for everyone. Showing favoritism breeds feelings of bitterness and division within the community.
Lack of Compassion
If the church isn’t concerned with social issues or the needs of the less fortunate, it might be missing the heart of Jesus’ teachings. A compassionate community should be actively involved in helping others without any prejudices.
Manipulative Tactics
Churches that use guilt, fear, or shame to influence behavior are definitely crossing a line. Genuine faith should be built on love and encouragement, not manipulation or emotional pressure.
Obsession with the End Times
Constantly dwelling on doomsday predictions or apocalyptic events can instill unnecessary anxiety and divert our attention. A well-rounded church should offer support and motivation rather than solely instilling fear about the future.
Pushing Isolation from Other Religions or Non-Believers
Discouraging members from interacting with non-believers or people of other faiths can lead to unhealthy isolation. A church should foster understanding and positive relationships, not separation. After all, we can still choose to be kind no matter how different our beliefs are.
Ignoring Mental Health
A church that dismisses mental health issues as mere lack of faith or doesn’t provide support for those struggling is missing an important aspect of care. Mental health is crucial and should be addressed with compassion and understanding.
Doesn’t Take Criticism Very Well
We all know that constructive criticism is essential for growth and improvement within any community. A church that reacts poorly to constructive criticism or feedback might be guilty or is avoiding necessary adjustments.
Discrimination
Any form of discrimination, whether based on race, gender, or sexual orientation, is unacceptable. A church should embody inclusivity and respect for all people, reflecting the love of Christ.
Overworking Volunteers
Volunteers should be appreciated and supported, not overburdened. If the church is demanding excessive time or resources without adequate support, it might be a sign of exploitation.
No Community Involvement
A church that focuses solely on its internal matters and neglects the surrounding community misses an important part of its purpose. Active involvement in the community shows a commitment to making a positive impact.
Indifference to Social Issues
A church that ignores or avoids engaging with social justice issues or community needs might not be fulfilling its role in advocating for change and support. It’s important for a church to be involved in addressing societal problems and helping those in need.
More From Hope No Matter What
14 Toxic Church Cultures that Should Be Done Away With
16 Troubling Issues Causing Christians to Abandon Their Faith
15 Myths People Misunderstand About the Afterlife
14 Lessons the Bible Reveals About Hell
Jannah is a dedicated Christian content writer with growing experience, driven by her love for sharing the message of faith. She brings dedication and passion to every piece she writes, drawing from her background as a former lector. Jannah is committed to creating meaningful and inspiring content that reflects her Christian values.