Many Christians get lost somewhere between faith and professional advice, especially when it comes to mental health. While the faith-based advice received comes from a place of love, it can actually make it harder for people in the church to get the help they need. Sometimes, the very words meant to console leave people feeling even more alone in a struggle.
It is only sensible and rational to think that faith and mental health care are complementary resources rather than mutually exclusive options. When we ignore the misunderstandings of mental illness in our churches, we leave our brothers and sisters to face their battles alone. Just as Jesus cared for both the spirit and body, every Christian deserves the support that tends to both their spiritual and mental well-being.
By being aware of these 12 common yet sabotaging beliefs, we can build a community where people feel free to find all the help they need without fearing judgment or repercussions.
Mental Illness is a Spiritual Issue
While spiritual well-being is crucial for overall health, viewing mental illness solely as a spiritual matter overlooks its biological and psychological components. Just as Jesus healed both body and spirit (Mark 2:1-12), modern understanding shows that mental health requires a holistic approach.
Believing mental illness is solely a spiritual issue becomes harmful when it prevents people from seeking necessary professional help, potentially prolonging suffering that could be addressed through a combination of spiritual support and professional medical care. Understanding that God can work through both spiritual guidance and medical treatment creates a more complete path to healing.
Prayer is Sufficient
“Be anxious for nothing, but in everything by prayer and supplication, with thanksgiving, let your requests be made known to God; and the peace of God, which surpasses all understanding, will guard your hearts and minds through Christ Jesus.” – Philippians 4:6-7
As the above scripture affirms, prayer is undoubtedly powerful and essential in a believer’s life. However, believing that prayer alone is always sufficient for mental health challenges can be dangerous. God has blessed us with medical knowledge and healing professionals as instruments of His care.
When someone believes prayer is the only acceptable solution, they might feel guilty or spiritually inadequate if their mental health doesn’t improve through prayer alone. This can lead to shame, hidden suffering, and worsening conditions that could have been helped through professional treatment alongside prayer.
Suffering is a Weak Sign of Faith
Consider some of the strongest believers in the Bible – they weren’t strangers to pain and struggle. Job, the man whom God called “blameless,” endured terrible struggles, and even the great apostle Paul talked about painful trials, describing a “thorn in the flesh” that wouldn’t disappear (2 Corinthians 12:7-9). They both learned that being strong did not mean a perfect life; it meant that God’s strength could work through their weaknesses.
When we interpret mental illness as a sign of a weak faith, it’s almost as if we are saying that this person isn’t a good Christian because they’re having a difficult time. Such thinking is what leads most to hide their pain.
Often, they become ashamed and start withdrawing from society rather than reaching out for help. But seeking help from your church community, friends, or mental health providers is not a sign of weakness. Just like David poured out his heart in the Psalms, there’s real strength in being honest about our struggles and accepting help when we need it.
Emotional Distress is a Sin
Labeling emotional distress as sinful contradicts Jesus’s own experiences of deep emotion. He wept at Lazarus’s tomb (John 11:35) and experienced anguish in Gethsemane (Matthew 26:38). Emotions are part of our God-given human nature, and experiencing them isn’t sinful. This belief becomes particularly harmful when it causes people to suppress or deny their emotions, leading to deeper psychological issues.
Obedience to God Will Cure Mental Illness
While spiritual discipline and obedience are important aspects of Christian life, viewing them as a guaranteed cure for mental illness can be devastating. The Bible shows righteous people facing ongoing challenges – Paul’s previously mentioned “thorn in the flesh” remained despite his faithfulness.
Suggesting that continued mental health struggles result from insufficient obedience could lead to guilt and spiritual confusion. It may cause people to question their faith or relationship with God when their symptoms persist despite faithful living.
Understanding that God’s love and our salvation aren’t dependent on our mental health status allows for a more gracious approach to treatment and recovery.
Christians Shouldn’t Take Medication for Mental Health
This belief often stems from misunderstanding God’s healing methods. Consider Luke, a physician but also one of Jesus’s closest followers, showing that medicine and faith can coexist. Just as we take medication for physical ailments, mental health medications can be vital tools for healing.
Refusing medical treatment becomes dangerous when it prevents people from receiving potentially life-saving care. Brain chemistry imbalances, like any other medical condition, may require medication to restore proper function. Refusing medication based on religious grounds can lead to unnecessary suffering and potentially dangerous situations that could have been prevented.
Mental Health Issues are Temporary
Sometimes, people think mental health struggles are like catching a cold – that they’ll just go away on their own after a short while. But that’s not always true. Look at King David in the Bible throughout the Psalms, we see him going through deep emotional ups and downs that lasted for long periods. At times, he was joyful, other times, he felt completely overwhelmed by sadness. These weren’t just quick moments that passed – they were real struggles that took time to work through.
When we expect mental health challenges to disappear quickly, it’s like telling someone with, say, diabetes they should be “over it” by now. This terrible way of thinking can make people feel like they’re failing when their struggles don’t vanish right away.
But just as some people need long-term care for physical conditions like asthma or heart problems, some mental health conditions need ongoing care and support, too. There’s nothing wrong with needing help for a long time. It’s simply part of taking good care of yourself, body, mind, and soul.
No Need to Seek Therapy, Only Counseling from a Pastor
While pastoral counsel is valuable, assuming it’s the only necessary source of mental health support can limit healing opportunities. Proverbs 11:14 says, “in abundance of counselors there is victory.”
Pastors often recognize their limitations and refer people to mental health professionals when needed. Believing that only a pastor’s counsel is enough becomes problematic when it prevents access to specialized care that could provide essential tools and treatments.
Professional therapists can offer specific techniques and insights that complement spiritual guidance, creating a more comprehensive approach to mental wellness. Both pastoral and professional counseling can work together for more effective support.
Misinterpretation of Scripture
Taking Bible verses out of context or applying them inappropriately to mental health situations can cause significant harm. For example, “be anxious for nothing” (Philippians 4:6) doesn’t mean anxiety disorders don’t exist or shouldn’t be treated.
Misinterpreting scripture can become dangerous when it is used to dismiss or minimize genuine mental health concerns. It can lead to shame, confusion, and resistance to necessary treatment. Understanding scripture in its proper context while recognizing that the Bible supports caring for both body and mind (1 Corinthians 6:19-20) provides a more balanced approach to mental health care.
Christianity Can Cure Mental Illness
While faith provides crucial support and hope, viewing Christianity as a complete cure for mental illness can be harmful. It becomes particularly problematic when it creates unrealistic expectations and disappointment if complete healing doesn’t occur through faith alone.
When symptoms persist, it may cause people to question their salvation or God’s love. Understanding that God often works through multiple healing channels, including medical treatment, provides a more complete approach to mental health care.
Emotions Like Anger, Sadness, or Fear Are Signs of Unforgiveness or Spiritual Deficiency
This belief contradicts the full range of emotions expressed throughout scripture, including by Jesus himself. He displayed righteous anger (Mark 11:15-17), deep sadness (Luke 19:41), and other strong emotions.
Believing otherwise becomes harmful when it causes people to suppress normal emotions or feel spiritually inadequate for experiencing them. It can prevent healthy emotional processing and lead to more severe psychological issues. Understanding that God created us as emotional beings and that expressing emotions appropriately is part of a healthy spiritual and mental life allows for better emotional regulation and overall well-being.
Walking Together in Grace and Understanding
The journey toward mental wellness in Christian communities requires both faith and understanding. As we grow in knowledge about mental health, we can create spaces where spiritual and emotional needs are met with compassion and wisdom. Remember that seeking help isn’t a sign of weak faith—it’s often an act of courage and strength that God has given us.
Let’s continue to support one another with grace, understanding that healing can come through both divine intervention and the gifts of medical science that God has provided.
More From Hope No Matter What
15 Common Reasons People Reject Jesus
15 Misconceptions About Jesus Christ That the Bible Addresses
18 Misconceptions About the Ten Commandments That Most People Get Wrong
10 Common Myths About King David That Aren’t True
