We often claim that our churches are newcomer-friendly. We display “All Are Welcome” signs, designate parking areas for visitors, and assign friendly greeters at the doors. However, despite our best efforts, we may unknowingly make newcomers feel out of place.
Our lack of good intentions isn’t the issue; instead, it’s the blind spots that develop over time. As regular members, we grow so accustomed to certain practices, languages, and traditions that we overlook how they might affect someone new. What feels normal to us might seem confusing, overwhelming, or even unapproachable to a first-time visitor. These small but impactful missteps often go unnoticed by those familiar with the environment but can discourage newcomers from returning or connecting further.
This article takes a closer look at 14 subtle ways churches may unintentionally create barriers and offers practical insights to help us foster a more welcoming environment for everyone who steps inside.
Lack of Greeting
How would you feel if you walked into a crowded room where everyone seems to know each other, but no one acknowledges your presence? It feels alienating, right? That is how first-time visitors feel at churches where greeting is overlooked or inconsistent. The initial moments upon entering a church are crucial as it shapes how visitors perceive the entire experience. When left to navigate the space alone, visitors often feel invisible and unwanted.
Creating a truly welcoming atmosphere starts with a dedicated team of approachable greeters who genuinely engage with everyone who walks through the doors. But it doesn’t stop there – regular attendees play a vital role, too. A simple smile, handshake, or “Good morning” to someone new can make a lasting impression. When everyone takes ownership of making others feel valued, the church reflects Christ’s inclusive love, and no one feels left out.
Over-Enthusiastic Greeting
While a lack of greeting can alienate newcomers, being too intense or overwhelming with greetings is equally problematic. Some people prefer to quietly observe or ease into a new environment without being immediately bombarded with attention. Over-enthusiastic greetings, such as a group swarming a visitor or pressing them for personal information, might make them feel uncomfortable or pressured.
A balanced approach is key. A genuine smile and a short, warm introduction can strike the right chord. Offering help, like showing someone to a seat or explaining how the service works, can feel thoughtful without being overbearing. Respecting personal space and reading social cues ensures visitors feel welcomed but not overwhelmed.
The “You’re in My Seat” Syndrome
Nothing makes visitors feel more awkward than being told that they’ve taken “someone’s seat.” Churches don’t usually give out assigned seats, but unwritten seating habits often emerge, especially among long-time church members. This leads to uncomfortable situations when newcomers unknowingly sit in spots that regular attendees view as “theirs.”
To break down this barrier, church members can adopt an open-handed approach to seating. Letting go of the idea that certain areas or seats belong to specific people encourages a spirit of inclusivity. A truly welcoming church embraces newcomers even if it means adjusting familiar routines. Such small sacrifices demonstrate a Christ-like attitude that values others more than personal preferences.
Controversial Sermons
While churches shouldn’t shy away from addressing important issues, diving into controversial topics without proper context or sensitivity can alienate visitors who are still forming their first impressions. Complex social or political issues, in particular, can cause discomfort when discussed without acknowledging diverse perspectives or the presence of those who might disagree.
The solution isn’t to avoid difficult topics but to approach them with wisdom and sensitivity to where people are in their spiritual journey. This approach includes providing context, acknowledging complexity, and creating safe spaces for questions and discussions. When controversial topics arise, leaders should demonstrate how to engage with differing viewpoints respectfully and graciously.
Overemphasis on Tithing
While giving is an important biblical principle, excessive focus on tithing can make visitors feel like the church is more interested in their wallets than their spiritual growth. Many first-time guests already harbor concerns about churches focusing primarily on money, and frequent or forceful appeals for donations can only strengthen these worries.
Churches should approach the topic of giving with sensitivity and wisdom, particularly when visitors are present. They might limit detailed financial discussions to member meetings, provide multiple discrete ways to give, and balance conversations about stewardship with explanations of how their resources serve the community and advance the church’s mission.
Cliquish Behavior
One of the most common barriers to church inclusivity is the formation of tight-knit social groups that, while providing a valuable community for members, can become impenetrable to newcomers. These cliques often manifest in the way people gather before and after services, with established members clustering in familiar groups while visitors stand awkwardly on the sidelines.
To address this, both leaders and members must take intentional steps to foster inclusivity. Simple practices can make a significant difference, like a “two-minute rule” where members prioritize greeting someone new after service. Additionally, organizing mixed-group events or rotating small-group gatherings can encourage interactions between established members and newcomers. By valuing inclusion alongside close friendships, churches can create an open and inviting community.
Insider Language
Over time, churches tend to create their own language and set of special terms, acronyms, and inside jokes. Words like “small groups” and “VBS” or casual mentions of past events might make sense to regulars but can leave newcomers feeling lost.
To make sure no one feels left out, it’s important for church leaders and members to be mindful of the language they use. They might try explaining unfamiliar terms or offering a quick rundown of key programs during announcements to make newcomers feel more comfortable and included. The goal is to ensure that everyone can engage fully without feeling like outsiders.
Using Church Jargon
Beyond basic insider language, churches often use specific theological or denominational jargon that can confuse or intimidate newcomers. Terms like “sanctification,” “covered by blood,” or even “gospel” might be second nature to long-time members but can be confusing or overwhelming for those new to church culture.
Church leaders and long-time members should develop a habit of explaining theological terms naturally. Providing resources, such as glossaries of common church vocabulary, can also help visitors feel informed and included, ensuring they engage fully without feeling out of place.
Assumed Knowledge in Service
A first-time churchgoer might feel overwhelmed when trying to follow a church service. People might expect everyone to know the rituals, like when to stand up, sit down, or participate in specific practices like communion. If nobody explains what to do, new visitors often feel confused, awkward, and left out of the whole worship thing.
Church leaders can make services more inclusive by providing context for practices and messages. Briefly explaining what’s happening or including simple instructions, like when to stand or sit, ensures everyone feels comfortable and included. A little clarity goes a long way in making visitors feel at home.
Inaccessible Facilities
Physical accessibility issues can become a barrier for those with mobility challenges or parents with little kids. Things like unclear signage, inconvenient parking, or a lack of accessibility features can make going to church a real hassle.
To avoid this issue, church leaders should evaluate facilities through the lens of accessibility. This may mean putting up clear signages, maintaining well-lit and obstacle-free pathways, adding handicapped parking spaces, and accommodating families with strollers or elderly attendees. These practical adjustments enhance accessibility while sending a clear message that everyone is valued and welcome.
Ignoring Newcomers’ Questions
People who visit a church for the first time are expected to have a few questions. If no one pays attention to their concerns or answers their questions, they might feel unwanted or unimportant.
To ensure new visitors feel supported, churches can create an environment that welcomes and addresses questions. Clear signs and an easy way to ask for help, such as a welcome desk, can give visitors confidence in finding their way around the church. When church members take the time to answer questions, it shows that the church values hospitality.
Poor Follow-Up
Many churches excel at initial greetings but struggle with meaningful follow-up. This can be particularly disappointing for those who’ve taken the significant step of sharing their contact information.
Effective follow-up requires a systematic approach that respects boundaries while maintaining connection. Churches might consider a clear process for handling visitor information, designated team members responsible for follow-up, and multiple options for visitors to engage further with the church community at their own pace.
Exclusivity in Worship Style
A rigid focus on one worship style can unintentionally alienate some attendees. People from different cultural or generational backgrounds may struggle to connect with a style that feels unfamiliar or exclusionary.
Balancing diversity in worship by incorporating both modern and traditional elements helps create an inclusive environment and shows that everyone’s worship preferences are valued.
Generational Blind Spots
Churches sometimes unintentionally cater more to one generation, leaving others feeling excluded. Whether it’s overly focusing on youth programs or neglecting the needs of older adults, failing to balance generational preferences can divide the congregation.
Addressing generational blind spots requires an intentional effort to understand and accommodate different age groups’ needs and preferences. This might include forming multi-generational leadership teams, regularly gathering feedback from different age groups, and ensuring that church programs and communications consider various generational perspectives and needs.
Building a Truly Welcoming Church
Building a welcoming church doesn’t require grand gestures. We can practice small, intentional ways to show love and care to everyone who visits or attends church services. The goal isn’t to completely reorganize church life around visitors but to remove unnecessary obstacles that prevent people from experiencing the community and the message the church wants to share. Small changes in awareness and practice can make a significant difference in helping visitors feel welcomed and included.
More From Hope No Matter What
10 Common Myths About King David That Aren’t True
13 Lies Christians Believe About Their Faith that Lead to Discouragement
15 Common Reasons People Reject Jesus
15 Misconceptions About Jesus Christ That the Bible Addresses
Vidivir is a dedicated high school teacher and a loving mother of three. With over a decade of experience as a blogger and article writer, she has honed her craft in storytelling. As a devoted church lector and servant of God, she combines her passion for writing with her faith, aiming to inspire others through her words.