Sharing faith often feels like walking on eggshells. While spreading the good news of Jesus is beautiful, some approaches might actually push people away instead of drawing them closer to God’s love. Many believers have the best intentions but sometimes miss the mark in how they share their faith.
This article looks at 12 common mistakes in evangelism and offers gentle insights on how we can better share God’s love in ways that truly touch hearts.
Aggressive Confrontation
Picture someone shouting about faith on a street corner, pointing fingers, and demanding immediate decisions. This approach often scares people away rather than draws them in. Jesus never forced anyone to listen – He spoke with gentleness and respect. When someone feels attacked, they’ll likely put up walls instead of opening their hearts to hear about God’s love.
“One-Size-Fits-All” Approach
Imagine trying to fit everyone with the same size shoe – it just doesn’t work! Each person’s journey with God is unique. Jesus talked differently to Nicodemus, a religious scholar, than He did to the woman at the well. When we treat everyone the same way, we miss the beautiful opportunity to connect with their personal story and specific needs.
Insufficient Relationships with Non-Christians
Living in a “Christian bubble” makes it hard to understand where others are coming from. Jesus spent time with all kinds of people—tax collectors, fishermen, and those that society rejected. Real friendships with people outside the church help us understand their questions and concerns, making our faith conversations more genuine and meaningful.
Using Fear or Guilt
“Or do you show contempt for the riches of his kindness, forbearance, and patience, not realizing that God’s kindness is intended to lead you to repentance?” – Romans 2:4
Using fear and guilt to bring people to faith often creates the wrong foundation for a genuine relationship with God. When evangelists lead with threats of eternal punishment or try to shame people for their choices, they overshadow the core message of Christianity – God’s unconditional love and grace.
God’s approach is different. He draws people to Himself through kindness and love, not fear or manipulation. Romans 2:4 reminds us that His goodness leads people to change their hearts. When people truly understand how deeply God loves them, they’re naturally drawn to respond to that love rather than running away in fear.
Manipulating Emotional Appeals
Using emotional tactics like intense background music, dramatic testimonies, or high-pressure altar calls might lead to quick decisions about faith. However, these moments often create a shaky foundation – like building a house on sand. When the emotional high wears off, people may feel confused or manipulated rather than genuinely transformed.
Real faith grows when both the heart and mind are honestly engaged with God. Rather than manufacturing emotional moments, sharing faith should involve genuine conversations, authentic relationships, and allowing the Holy Spirit to work in His own timing. This approach might take longer, but it leads to lasting faith built on truth and understanding rather than temporary feelings.
Lack of Personal Experience
Talking about God without being able to share personal experiences of His work in your life makes the message feel hollow and unconvincing. Just as you wouldn’t trust someone recommending a restaurant they’ve never visited, people are less likely to believe in the power of faith when the messenger can’t share how it has personally impacted them.
Personal testimonies bridge the gap between theory and reality. When we openly share our struggles, victories, and everyday moments with God, others can see that faith is more than just religious words – it’s a living, breathing relationship that changes lives. These real-life stories help people connect with the practical ways God works in our daily experiences, making the message of salvation more tangible and relatable.
Using Simplistic or Misleading Phrases
Using oversimplified phrases or religious clichés can make light of people’s genuine life challenges and questions about faith. When we reduce the Gospel to quick fixes like “just pray this prayer” or make empty promises that “Jesus will fix everything,” we risk minimizing the reality of human struggles and the depth of God’s work in our lives. These simplistic approaches can leave people feeling dismissed or misunderstood.
True faith embraces simplicity and depth, just like Jesus used everyday examples to explain profound spiritual truths. When sharing the Gospel, it’s essential to take time to listen, acknowledge real struggles, and demonstrate God’s love in clear, relatable terms that people can understand. This means moving beyond Christian jargon and connecting with people where they are, showing how God’s truth speaks to their specific situations and concerns.
Focus on Numbers Over Relationships
When evangelism becomes focused on numbers – counting raised hands, baptisms, or decision cards – it can lose sight of Jesus’s heart for genuine transformation. Just as Jesus invested time in building relationships with His disciples, true evangelism isn’t about quick wins or statistical achievements. He showed us that each person’s journey to faith is unique and deserves patient, loving attention.
The path to authentic faith involves more than a moment of decision – it requires ongoing discipleship and genuine community. When we rush people to make quick decisions without providing support for their spiritual growth, many may drift away from their initial commitment. Jesus’s example teaches us to value quality over quantity, focusing on helping people build a lasting relationship with God rather than just adding to our conversion numbers.
Judgmental Attitudes
Looking down on others while sharing faith is like offering a meal with a side of criticism – nobody wants that! Jesus showed love to everyone, even those others condemned. When we remember our own need for grace, we share faith with humility and compassion.
Ignoring the Role of Works and Action
Simply talking about faith while failing to demonstrate it through actions creates an empty message that lacks credibility. Like clouds that promise rain but never deliver, speaking about God’s love without showing it through practical acts of kindness leaves people questioning the authenticity of our faith. As James 2:17 reminds us, “Faith by itself, if it is not accompanied by action, is dead.”
The most powerful testimony comes when people witness faith in action through genuine acts of service, kindness, and care for others. When believers actively demonstrate God’s love by meeting practical needs, showing consistent compassion, and serving their communities, it naturally draws people to ask questions about the source of such love. This living demonstration of faith often speaks louder than any spoken message and makes people more receptive to hearing about the God who motivates such actions.
Overemphasis on Doctrine at the Expense of Relationship
When we focus too much on explaining complex Bible teachings and winning religious arguments, we can forget what matters most – showing God’s love. It’s like trying to teach someone advanced math before they’ve learned basic numbers. Jesus always started by being a friend and showing kindness to people before He taught them deeper spiritual lessons. Building relationships and showing genuine care opens doors that arguments never will.
When people feel loved and accepted first, they naturally become more interested in learning about faith. Jesus showed us this simple truth: love comes first, then teaching. When someone experiences real Christian love, they’re more likely to want to understand the God behind that love.
Ignoring the Freedom of Choice
Using pressure or manipulation to push someone into making a faith decision robs them of genuine choice in their spiritual journey. It’s like forcing someone to say “I love you” – the words might be there, but the heart isn’t. Jesus demonstrated this beautifully when He allowed the rich young ruler to walk away, even though He loved him (Mark 10:21-22).
God gave everyone the freedom to choose or reject His love – that’s what makes faith real and meaningful. When someone comes to faith through their own free choice, responding to God’s gentle invitation rather than human pressure, it creates a genuine relationship with God that can last. This kind of authentic faith grows from a heart that has freely said “yes” to God’s love.
Reimagining How We Share Jesus Today
Think of sharing faith like planting a garden – it takes patience, care, and the right approach. The best evangelism happens naturally through genuine relationships, sincere love, and lives that reflect Jesus. When we focus on loving people like Jesus did, we create space for authentic faith conversations.
Remember, God works differently in everyone’s life, and that’s beautiful. By avoiding these common pitfalls and focusing on genuine love and respect, we can share our faith in ways that draw people toward God’s amazing love rather than push them away.
More From Hope No Matter What
15 Common Reasons People Reject Jesus
15 Misconceptions About Jesus Christ That the Bible Addresses
18 Misconceptions About the Ten Commandments That Most People Get Wrong
10 Common Myths About King David That Aren’t True
